According to Frank Rvekamp - marketing manager of Vodafone - are the services 'on no single manner' with each other to compare. Who however to both services looks, can till no other conclusion come that they well thoroughly awful many on each other appear. he. Vodafone has looked at well i-fashion, as many is clear. Only there are also enough differences.
Sites
Both services work via the gprs-network, that uses becomes meanwhile through four of the five Dutch telecomcompanies. Hereby is not paid for the time that one online is, but for the quantity receive data.,. The telephone conversations lapse otherwise normally via the slower gsm-network. One of the possibilities with i-fashion and Live is the claiming of websites. This are no usual html-page' s. By i-fashion becomes use made of an own standard, Vodafone sees more in an open size: weapon.
Both services make further use of a number officile content partners that taken up become in the menu of the apparatuses. For many services becomes count asked. The partners pay hereby approximately 15 per cent at KPN and Vodafone. Of the 1 Euro subscriptions expense on for instance the peoples paper goes thus 15 penny to the operator.
For the subscriber of i-fashion its present 104 officile sites available, of which are there 35 free of charge accessible. Vodafone comes not yet further now then fifty. At the end of the year, that will be it to expectation eighty. Also here approximately eenderde is free of charge accessible. Next to the officile sites, both services know a large number not-officile sites.
E-mail
Someone else popular application is e-mail. In this do not differ the services particularly many. As well the subscriber of i-fashion as of Vodafone Live a special mailadres gets for its apparatus. Furthermore they can want to raise by their own internetprovider.
An important difference is how the providers with spam go around. KPN is with this a to pieces further. Since last month offers i-fashion are customers namely the possibility self to fix whose she want to want receive. It is with these so-called 'white ruse' possible a specific mailadres on to give, but commit also round mailadressen of groups or on to take. From the introduction, users got all the disposition about a 'black ruse' by which indicated becomes whose gn receive e-mail may become.
Vodafone considers is not yet so far such measures also, but. The some what the telecomprovider now yet does, is the stopping e-mail of of known spammers.
Apparatuses
That i-fashion already longer on the market is, will not yet say that before more apparatuses available are. On the contrary. Still the customer has here only n choice: the NEC n21i. It is wait yet always on the all long announced Toshiba TS21i. Vodafone has stand immediately by introduction all three apparatuses ready: the Sharp GX 10, Nokia 7650 and Panasonic GD87. These all are foresee a built in camera.
KPN can offer in exchange hereby alone a proper price advantage. The NEC-apparatus costs currently only 49 Euros in combination with a subscription. The cheapest Vodafone-apparatus (the Sharp) is with 299 Euros a to pieces more precious. Advantage is however the built in camera and the something more compact size.
MMS
Ht sharpen on which Vodafone self of its competitor distinguishes is the possibility for mms (Multimedia Messaging Services). The with the three apparatuses taken snapshots can immediately to someone else apparatus be sent or - as that apparatus it not for arranged is - to someone else site. Various opera torsos expect many of this expansion on sms.
KPN is not yet so far and comes just on be early the second quarter of 2003 with mms for the i-fashion. The group want firstly certain knowledge that the exchange between the different opera torso immaculately lapses. Now is that indeed not yet the case. A subscriber of Vodafone can send Am for instance no mms' you to a subscriber from.
Games, ring barrel
With both services, various games can be played. The downloading of yet more games costs by Vodafone vigorously much extra per game: until 5 Euros. The same counts for the polyfone ring barrel, that in all cases 1.50 per to pieces expenses. By KPN is not extra necessary to become per game or belmelodie settled. The customer must take here a subscription on a ring tone-site for 2 Euros per month.
Prices
A not unimportant consideration in the comparison is naturally the prices that both opera torso ask for their services. First requirement is an usual subscription on KPN or Vodafone. By i-fashion, beside it must be paid in all cases 3 Euros per month extra. Vodafone offers to take on the other hand the possibility no extra subscription. The customer is in that case 0,0244 Euros per KB rid. A mms costs 49 euro penny.
On top the bundles ask both groups supplementary amounts for the downloading of ring barrel, games and the selling a subscription on sites. This last one is expensiver by Vodafone in some cases. KPN handles namely a bovengrens of 2 Euros per month. Vodafone puts border no on its content partners, through which a month subscription on for instance PSV only gladly 4 Euros expense.
For the rest, KPN has five different bundles: 200 KB for in totally 5 Euros, 1 MB for 13 Euros, 5 MB for 18 Euros, 10 MB for 28 Euros and 25 MB for 48 Euros. By Vodafone, this is 250 KB for 5 Euros, 1 MB for 10 Euros, 5 MB for 15 Euros, 20 MB for 45 Euros and 50 MB for 100 Euros. The price per KB is by Vodafone thus about the entire line something layer. See this table for a detailed survey.
With 1 MB, the customer can claim approximately hundred pages, read hundred mails of thousand signs, claim five ring barrel and download five games.
Experience
As well KPN as a Vodafone addresses with their mobile internet services in first authority on the consumers market. For younger persons with name, affairs as a sms/mms, messaging will and ring barrel the largest attraction have, interesting want to be while for the older early probable a subscription on for instance traffic information or the ANP.
Of the surfen, one must not have otherwise all too high expectations. Gprs is a whole improvement with respect to gsm, but is for the with broad tie spoiled surfer yet always very slow. Especially by it away and again connect within the online menus much has been tolerated necessary, because here every turn made becomes again again a connection.
By Vodafone falls on that not yet everything optimally works, but that will run-up problems be. As give different affairs - as the downloading of PacMan for only gladly 5 Euros - for days the report that there 'on this moment technical problems' are.
Also by Vodafone Live, a number of services as the Financile Telegraph, the telephone Directory and the ANP is not yet available.
Conclusion
The services do not differ particularly many of each other. Vodafone has as an extraatje the possibility for the taking of photographs and mms. KPN offers on the other hand more weapons against spam. Further is the apparatus for i-fashion considerably more cheaply than the three apparatuses that Vodafone now available has. Also is the downloading of games and ring barrel by Vodafone expensivelyer because here per to pieces is settled. The subscriptions its by Vodafone however again something more advantageously.
officile sites:
Imode website
Vodafone website